Shona Ghosh


Criminality, social media and #Twitterjoketrial
November 11, 2010, 11:35 pm
Filed under: Internet, Law, Social media | Tags: ,

As several commentators wryly observed, today is the day David Cameron told China off (sort of) for impinging on free speech, while in the UK the justice system found Paul Chambers guilty of (wait for it) ‘menace’ for the following tweet:

Crap! Robin Hood airport is closed. You’ve got a week and a bit to get your shit together otherwise I’m blowing the airport sky high!

A colleague of mine remarked that Chambers losing his appeal was ultimately a good thing, demonstrating that the UK was taking terror threats seriously. But the British law should not, cannot be manipulated to hold an easy scapegoat up as an example – it’s an insult to the public intelligence, particularly when there are genuine terrorist threats to combat.

Honestly, what kind of message does this send out? That people aren’t permitted to occasionally vent their frustration in public, however ill-advised? Or that the police are still technologically illiterate and might look to analyse the context and impetus for an online message before embarking on a massive, tax-wasting joke of an investigation? Illiterate might be a strong term – but the Paul Chambers investigation began in January. The police didn’t announce any kind of ‘social media training’ to help carry out investigations online until May this year.

A sad day for flippancy and freedom of speech.



Tabloid-bashing part 1: News of the World and phone hacking
October 6, 2010, 1:27 pm
Filed under: Law, Media | Tags: ,

The red-tops are having a hard time of it this week, with a resurgence of interest in the ongoing phone hacking scandal, and Chris Atkins debating the falseness of tabloid news.

Though the phone-hacking saga kicked off in 2008, the story has reignited recently after the New York Times published a lengthy feature article last month and Channel 4 aired its Dispatches investigation last night. There is renewed pressure on former NoW editor Andy Coulson to admit knowledge of NoW reporters’ hacking private phone conversations and increasing public awareness and disgust with the tabloid ‘dark arts’.

(more…)



Frontline Club: rise of the ‘superinjunction’
April 14, 2010, 10:17 pm
Filed under: Law, Media | Tags: , , , , ,

It was too good to be true – Carter Ruck and Simon Singh in the same room! Debating libel law! Rargh!

In the wake of the online campaign to reform British libel law, the Frontline Club put together a panel to debate privacy, gagging orders/superinjunctions and whether current laws are a threat to press freedom in the UK.

On the panel were Nigel Tait for Carter-F..Ruck; David Leigh, Guardian investigations editor (he testified during the Trafigura case); science journalist Simon Singh and a slightly nicer lawyer called David Hooper just to make Nigel more comfortable. I had been hoping for bloodshed but sadly there was none. Though the Carter-Rucker did turn up with a ‘The Guardian hates me’ badge pinned to his lapel. (more…)




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.